Choosing between long and short nails for playing Classical Guitar
Some classical guitarists prefer to pluck the strings with the nails of their right hand while other guitarists prefer to keep their nails trimmed and to pluck the strings with the tips of their fingers. If you are a beginner classical guitarist you might be wondering which way you should play.You can start with no nails at all playing like that for one year or so.In that way you will find the right attack of the fingers.Only after that you could let them to grow.
Here are some insights about each way so you can make a decision as to which style is right for you.
The most important thing about playing classical guitar is the playing! It is true that the oscillating back and forth between long and short nails has an effect on the virtuosity but this switching also brings a benefit. The two different styles of playing produce two very different tones and this awareness of tone improves the ear and the ability to express yorself with the guitar. It helps you to better tap into the incredible range of tone the guitar is capable of.
Long Nails
Long nails give you a more vibrant tone, better volume and faster speed. But long nails can be a real maintenance headache. You have to keep them very carefully trimmed and watch out for their welfare in your normal life.
Short Nails
Short Nails do not produce as loud a volume, do not lend themselves to the fastest playing but do give you more control and more sensitivity in your playing. There is more of an emotional connection with the music because you literally touch the strings. Short nails are also easier to maintain and easier to integrate into the rest of your life.
So which should you use?
My recommendation for you is that if your intent is to be a professional classical guitarist you should cultivate your playing experimenting with both styles and see which you like.It can be a bit of a worry to have long, perfectly trimmed and manicured nails for playing yet always worry about breaking them. And breaking one nail seriously hampers, if not totally stops your ability to play. You will be running down to the local drug store to find a nail repair kit. Either way you go with your nails my biggest recommendation is that you not worry about it. The most important thing in classical guitar is the music and you should always think about what do you want to heare playing your guitar because its a beautiful instrument and it is going to sound fantastic.
John
Wed, 04/09/2008 - 06:28
Great site and useful content
creativeguitar.org
Sat, 03/01/2008 - 21:57
Yes you got a point 123
but the example you gaved me...
Paco is a Fmamenco musician guitarist Yes i and?
So being a classical guitaris i would not want to play classical music with the sound Paco is playing beacuse this is another thing.I am not saying that it is not a good one i am just saying that it is another kind of sound and it is not the sound i want to heare.
I can asure you that not the muscle of the hand is giving you the tone volume etc but the spirit of the your soul and the music you play.
Yes i prefer also short nails i can have more control of the sound and more sensitivity in my playing
Best regard
Boris
Scaler
Sun, 02/24/2008 - 00:32
I agree with 123. Shorter nails are generally thought to be faster than long ones. Most current teaching encourages playing from the "spot" which is when both the flesh and nail contact the string. When executed properly it results in both a warm and clear tone. Minor adjustments in the angle of attack can then create a more brilliant (nail) or sweeter tone (flesh) to augment playing ponticella or dolce, that is closer to the bridge or closer to the fingerboard
flat3rd
Thu, 02/07/2008 - 17:05
I would agree with 123 above. I used to play with longer nails and a little higher bend in my right wrist, and I found the longer nails hard to maintain. When a nail did break, there was such an inconsistency in the sound and feel that it was hard to play until it was repaired or grew back out. By keeping my wrist a little straighter and the nails shorter I could get the same tone and volume with an increase in speed. The added benefit of not having to constantly having to worry about them was worth it alone. The main thing is to always keep them smooth so you dont get it snagged on clothing, etc, increasing your chance of breakage.
123
Mon, 02/04/2008 - 12:52
Well, this isn't quite researched. Look, for example, at Paco de Lucia's nails: short, he plays extremely fast if he wants to and has a beautiful tone and great volume too. (yes, but he plays flamenco some will say. And?...) The angle and way of attack, the muscles in the hand give the most part of the tone, volume and the other things. Personally, I can't understand how some people can play with very long nails. So my choice would be: short nails shaped to the right,with a correct angle of attack and strength in the hands.
Post new comment